With the exciting range of autos being offered in the Indian market, the question that is being increasingly asked is about the pricing. Are Indian cars overpriced? Ravi Shankar from Chennai said that his plan to upgrade to a new car from his current stead – a 2013 model Volkswagen Polo GT TSI – threw some weird challenges. “The Hyundai Alcazar with a starting price of INR 1,700,000 and Skoda Kushaq with a starting price of INR 1,700,000 lakh look overpriced. Considering the fact that localisation has gained since I bought my Polo, the car prices should go down rather than go up. My Polo, with an imported TSI engine and a DSG transmission, cost INR 930,000 lakh. The Polo GT TSI on offer today is priced at INR 1,174,000 approximately in Chennai,” said Ravi. He added, “Should the price not go down rather than go up?” Mahesh Murthy from Bangalore said that he has postponed his plan to upgrade from his 2012 Punto. He finds the current car prices exorbitant. 

A car dealer from Delhi expressed on the condition of not revealing his name that the interpretation or inference of a product being overpriced lies with the buyer. Cars today offer more creature comforts, safety and powertrain combinations, he said. This should justify their price, he added. Stating that a sub-four metre car costing close to or more than INR 1,500,000 is discomforting, Vikram Jagtap of Pune said that cars like these fit in a tax bracket that ensures a significant tax rebate. Asked if this was because of the regulations and features, he answered that the he is not certain if the addition of technologies and features like BS VI, airbags, ABS, ESP and EBD would lead to such a price escalation. Saikat from Kolkata averred cars like the Mahindra XUV300 and Tata Nexon offer among the best safety aspects if the preconception of buying a ‘big’ car at INR 1,500,000 is set aside. They offer a long list of safety features like seven airbags, ESP, ISOFIX seats, ABS, EBD, 5-Star GNCAP rating and more, he added. 
 

Is it features?
Rohan Srivastava from Kanpur informed that the long list of features in today’s new cars is their differentiator as well as a catalyst for price increase. They, to an extent, justify the price increase. The other factors include inflation, which has in turn led to a jump in raw material prices, he added. Drawing attention to the near 40 percent jump in steel prices, which has affected his business, Srivastava said that some Indian car segments are reasonably priced. Srivastava drives a Hyundai. Neelkanth Sawant, a marketing professional from Pune, who drives a Maruti, said that car prices have kept pace with inflation. What failed to keep up with the pace are salaries in most jobs. “It is therefore that those looking to upgrade their cars seven-to-ten years down the line are finding it difficult to choose a new set of wheels costing 1.5 to two times more,” he added. Of the opinion that an INR 10,00,000 priced car of yesteryear lacked features like airbags, ABS, EBD, touchscreen, longer warranty coverage, parking sensors, auto wipers and head lamps, sun roof, climate control and connected car tech, an auto enthusiast from Hyderabad said that factor in inflation, and it is not illogical to have the current version of the same model cost INR 1,700,000.  

Raveeraj from Bangalore averred manufacturers are pricing their autos as per the customer’s willingness to pay. The fact that most cars are well-equipped does not mean that they are overpriced, he added. Ajit Powar of Pune expressed cars in India tend to be overpriced than in many other markets of the world. They also tend to differ in quality, he quipped. Is it because laws concerning autos are perhaps not as strict as in the UK or the US? Powar could not provide a definitive answer. An industry observer stated that he has seen some companies practice a culture of using different materials in cars that they export. The grade of steel they use differs, the quality and thickness of paint they use differs and even the amount of insulation or features they offer is different, he said. This, he claimed, is done to address the stringent safety and other requirements of the export markets. In terms of emissions and safety, we lag behind the European and US markets, and yet the cars made in India are priced high. This has largely to do with the taxes and high cost of doing business, he explained. Ram Naresh of Hyderabad said that the TUV300 he bought in 2017 cost him INR 1,250,000 on road. On the top of it, he paid INR 250,000 as the loan interest. He spent around INR 50,000 on accessories. The total cost came to about INR 1,550,000. What he spent on diesel, service, spares, insurance etc. would amount to another INR 150,000 to INR two-lakh. Looking at upgrading to a new car, he is finding the prospect of spending INR 150,000 on a sub-four metre vehicle weird. 

Inflation, weak Indian rupee, taxes, policies or greed?
Ram Naresh’s search of the low-end versions of cars has made him conclude that they are overpriced. “The Harrier XE, for example, is quite bare bone,” he said. “I have decided to postpone my decision to buy a new vehicle. I am now looking for a used car instead,” he added. Blaming inflation, weakening Indian rupee, the greed of automakers to make huge profits and the knee jerk reaction of authorities, Rohit from Indore said that it is high time cars are looked upon as a necessity and taxed accordingly. Bala from Chennai averred that tax policies have led to a great extent for cars to be highly overpriced. Electric cars are also not being spared, he rued. Look at the prices of electric cars and it does not look like the government is encouraging them, he quipped. Dev Tahalwani, who operates a three-wheeler, said that he finds the price of the new Mahindra Treo Zor electric three-wheeler high. And, if I avail finance, the cost is going further up, he complained. Expressing surprise over the recent EY survey report about buyers being ready to pay a premium of up to 20 percent, an industry source mentioned that the price of electric cars on offer in India is definitely high. The operating costs of such vehicles, their range, their reliability and their usability in terms of infrastructure are values that are yet not clear. 
 

Checks and balances?
Of the opinion that law makers in US and Europe are far more aware and sensitive to the sentiments of buyers and the general public, an industry observer said that the situation in India has not matured as much. The level of checks and balances governing automakers in the US and Europe are simply not there, he added. Stating that inflation, depreciating Indian rupee, ever increasing taxes, availability of high tenure loans and stagnating incomes have already driven car prices to insane levels, Robin from Chennai mentioned that a good upgrade for a reasonable amount after four-to-five years is no longer in sight. Sanchit Chari from Bangalore said, “Taxes have remained the same for the last few years. When GST was rolled out, the rates were set to what the combination of pre-GST rates were (VAT, state taxes etc.). So, they are not the cause of price hikes. Their increase has been one-to-two percent, whereas the car prices have moved up by almost 30 to 50 percent during the same period.” “It needs to be investigated if the addition of safety and emission technologies as well as features would lead to an increase in prices to such a level,” he averred. Rajesh Tandel from Mumbai drew attention to the price escalation in some of the long running cars in India like the Toyota Innova. In 2005, the vehicle was launched at a starting price which was no more than INR seven lakh, he said. Today, he mentioned, the starting price of the same vehicle is no less than INR 1,600,000 lakh. An increase of INR eight-lakh for a product line that is not drastically different from that of 2005 is hard to grasp, he added. 

A Delhi-based industry source expressed that the level of taxes on an automobile (there’s GST and a compensation cess of 48 percent, the enormous registration tax that is a state subject and continues to rise time and again), regulatory requirements and the cost of doing business are responsible for the costs rising so much and so often in at least the last one year. The average buying capacity of an Indian buyer has not risen in line, he informed. Explaining that INR 10,00,000 (roughly USD 13,000) is more or less the same amount of money incurred to develop a modern car – a compact SUV or a typical sedan – in comparison to other markets the world over, the source said that it is the tax component that needs to be looked at. Of the opinion that taxes would amount to a good portion of the prices paid to buy cars, Rohit remarked, “The increase in car prices is mainly due to base increases by manufacturers. Taxes are a percentage of base price and increase as the base price increases.” “If one wants to compare prices of cars with those that are also found in the US, he or she could compare the ex-showroom price there and the ex-showroom price here,” he explained. Doing the same some years ago, Rohit concluded that the base price of a car in India is a bit higher than in the US. This, despite the higher labour and regulatory cost in that country. 

Mumbai-based automotive major Mahindra & Mahindra has announced its wholesales for April 2025 at 84,170 vehicles, a growth of 19 percent, including exports.

The auto major sold a total of 52,330 SUVs in the domestic market, which was 28 percent higher than 41,008 SUVs sold for the same period last year. Commercial vehicle sales in the domestic market came at 22,989 units, which was 4 percent YoY. 

Veejay Nakra, President, Automotive Division, Mahindra & Mahindra, said, “Building on the strong momentum of last year's performance, we began the year on a strong note in April by achieving SUV sales of 52,330 units, a growth of 28 percent and total vehicle sales of 84,170 units, a 19 percent growth over the same month last year. These numbers indicate the strength of our portfolio and customer offerings.”

JSW MG Motor India, a leading passenger vehicles manufacturer, has announced its wholesales for April 2025.

The company reported sales of 5,829 units, which was 23 percent higher over April 2024, when it sold 4,725 vehicles.

Interestingly, the automaker's popular offering, the Windsor EV, has continued to be the top-selling electric passenger vehicle for the seventh month in a row.

JSW MG Motor India's Windsor EV has now gone home to over 20,000 customers.

Maruti Suzuki India, the country’s largest carmaker, has reported its wholesales of 179,791 units in April 2025, marking a 7 percent increase compared to 168,089 units sold in April 2024. The growth was primarily propelled by strong performance in utility vehicles and a sharp rise in export volumes.

Domestic sales, including passenger and light commercial vehicles, remained flat with 142,053 units, as compared to 140,448 units in April 2024. Within this, light commercial vehicles (LCVs) like the Super Carry saw a significant jump of 34.2 percent, with sales rising to 3,349 units from 2,496 units last year.

In the passenger vehicle segment, SUVs such as the Brezza, Ertiga, Grand Vitara and others recorded a 4.4 percent increase, selling 59,022 units compared to 56,553 in the previous year. However, sales for Eeco declined by 5.2 percent, while the mini segment (Alto, S-Presso) saw a sharp 45 percent drop, falling to 6,332 units from 11,519 units. The compact segment, which includes high-volume models like the Baleno and Swift, grew by 8.1 percent, reaching 61,591 units.

Sales to Toyota Kirloskar Motor rose sharply by 79.2 percent, from 5,481 units to 9,827 units, indicating a growing demand for cross-badged products.

The standout performer was the export segment, which surged 26 percent to 27,911 units from 22,160 units in April 2024. This strong export growth helped bolster the company’s overall numbers despite weaknesses in domestic sub-segments.

While some product lines such as the mid-size sedan Ciaz (-63 percent) continue to struggle.

Tata Motors reported total wholesales of 72,753 units for April 2025, reflecting a 6 percent year-on-year decline from 77,521 units in April 2024.

The passenger vehicle (PV) segment, including electric vehicles, accounted for 45,532 units, down 5 percent from 47,983 units in the same month last year. Within this, domestic PV sales dropped 6 percent to 45,199 units, while international business (IB) sales rose significantly to 333 units, up from 100 units. Electric vehicle sales (domestic + IB) declined 16 percent year-on-year to 5,318 units.

Commercial vehicle (CV) sales stood at 27,221 units, marking an 8 percent YoY drop from 29,538 units in April 2024. Domestic CV sales contracted 10 percent to 25,764 units, while CV exports (IB) grew 43 percent to 1,457 units. Key sub-segments like Small Commercial Vehicles (SCV) and pickups saw a steep 23 percent decline.

Despite growth in certain categories like ILMCV trucks and passenger carriers, overall sales momentum was tempered across both PV and CV segments.